Progress to Some, a Hurdle for Others

While on surfing the Internet community on Facebook, I got a little sidetracked and came upon a link titled something along the lines of 'anti-pro-ana' to a group that attempted to spread the word about eating disorder groups. I searched for news stories and found one on newsweek that detailed about how these and groups of the other side are actually very numerous. Many have touted Facebook and other social networking sites as places where people can find others with similar interests as them, as well as keep in touch and keep up with friends. And with the sites growing at incredibly fast rates, there are more chances for people to find similar interest groups. Its usually said that this growing community of people and shared idea is a good thing. But, as we usually do in American Studies, we should put a question mark after saying that this is progress, and my discovery on Facebook today prompted that. With the Facebook population growing, people have created support groups for people with eating disorders. This isnt a support group to help teens get out of their disorder, but one that encourages girls to go on extreme diets to lose extreme amounts of weight. some even have places where members can post pictures of themselves and other users can comment on "problem areas". Like one former member said "I was encouraged to stop eating when I saw how many people were doing it". While the progress in many areas because of these sites is undeniable, there are other topics where these websites have caused damage, this being one of them. But to go even further and put a question on our question mark, there are some good sides to the groups that can be called progress. Marcia Herrin, a Dartmouth professor, is glad to see that teens are comfortable talking about eating disorders and arent as afraid to share and admit that they have a disorder. So while these networking sites are a progress in social communities and the spreading of ideas there always must be a question mark, because things dont always seem as they are. Then again though, you should look for yet another question mark; one that reveals a silver lining to a situation. When it comes to these groups, people have to decide if the progress the group presents is greater than the harm it causes, because every situation of progress has a question mark and a drawback.

By the way, I checked for the group again today but it turns out facebook deletes the groups when the find them because they violate the terms of agreement by "promoting self harm or Harm to others".